Garmin Sues TomTom (Again)
Garmin has filed a second patent infringement lawsuit this year against rival TomTom. The lawsuit, filed Aug. 23 in U.S. District Court in Marshall, Texas, alleges that TomTom is infringing on a patent that Garmin won in June. The patent is titled: "Portable navigation system and device with audible turn by turn directions." Patent Number 7,062,378.
In reading this patent, there are a lot of meaty claims in it that would pretty much cover the GPS market as it stands. The whole feature of adjusting your route if you make a wrong turn is in it (Claims 17/20), but the key claims are around offering audible directions. This would say that audible directions that are generated by a route are intellectual property owned by Garmin. Wow, that’s pretty broad. Can you imagine a GPS that doesn’t do that?
In February, Garmin sued TomTom in U.S. District Court in Madison, Wis., for infringing three navigation-related patents. In March, TomTom responded with a counterclaim that Garmin was infringing on three patents it held an exclusive license for. In April, TomTom bought the same patents for an undisclosed amount. That case awaits a February 2007 jury trial.
I’ve seen a couple of these types of suit, counter suit things, and a lot of times they end up battling for a long time and then settling, when the companies both realize that both of their product lines would be decimated if they can’t use each other’s technology. We’ll see what happens.
Read More in: GPS News
Share this Article with others:
Came straight to this page? Visit GPS Lodge for all the latest news.
Posted by Scott Martin at August 29, 2006 9:44 AM